myMedCrew leaf markmyMedCrew
Book a 20-minute call

Medical Necessity in Billing: How to Document It

Medical necessity is the payer's test that a service was reasonable and necessary to diagnose or treat the patient's condition. On a claim, it is proven by three things together: the diagnosis code, the chart note behind it, and the payer's coverage policy for that service.

Book a 20-minute call

For Medicare, the test comes from section 1862(a)(1)(A) of the Social Security Act, which excludes services "not reasonable and necessary for the diagnosis or treatment of illness or injury or to improve the functioning of a malformed body member" (Medicare Claims Processing Manual, Chapter 30). Commercial plans such as Anthem and Cigna publish their own definitions, built on a provider's "prudent clinical judgment".

It is where revenue leaks. In MGMA's January 2026 Stat poll of 288 practices, denials and appeals were the biggest revenue cycle leak at 48%, with denial leakage "centering on medical necessity and non-covered services" and "insufficient medical-necessity language" listed as a documentation gap.

In this guide: Definitions · Who decides · The chart · Diagnosis codes · E/M levels · ABN · Reading a denial · Appeals · Prevention · Who does the work · FAQ

What Is Medical Necessity?

What counts as medical necessity depends on who pays the claim. The two definitions a practice meets most:

Medicare. A service is excluded if it is not reasonable and necessary for diagnosis or treatment, or to improve the functioning of a malformed body member, under §1862(a)(1)(A). Chapter 30 of the Claims Processing Manual lists this as the statutory basis for "not reasonable and necessary" denials.

Commercial plans. Anthem's Medical Necessity Criteria (ADMIN.00004), published 1 July 2026, defines medically necessary services as those a medical practitioner, exercising prudent clinical judgment, would provide to prevent, evaluate, diagnose or treat an illness, injury or disease, and that are:

  • In accordance with generally accepted standards of medical practice
  • Clinically appropriate in type, frequency, extent, site and duration, and considered effective for the patient's condition
  • Not primarily for the convenience of the patient, physician or other provider
  • Not more costly than an alternative at least as likely to produce equivalent results

Cigna's medical necessity definition follows the same structure. Medically necessary in the clinical sense and payable on a claim aren't the same thing: the payer's definition and policy decide what it pays for.

Who Decides Whether a Service Is Medically Necessary?

The payer decides, using its written policy. For Medicare, those policies are national coverage determinations (NCDs) from CMS and local coverage determinations (LCDs) and billing articles from each Medicare Administrative Contractor, all searchable in the Medicare Coverage Database.

For commercial plans, it is the plan's medical policy, read against the member's contract. Anthem's policy states that federal and state law and contract language "take precedence over Medical Policy and must be considered first" in deciding coverage.

The provider still owns the clinical judgment. The policy decides payment; the chart has to show why the service met it.

What Must the Chart Contain to Support Medical Necessity?

The chart must show why this patient needed this service on this date, in terms the payer's policy recognizes. The policies and coders' own threads point to the same elements:

  • A specific reason for the visit. MGMA quotes Pam D'Apuzzo: a chief complaint that says "patient here without complaints" or "patient here for follow-up" is not a sufficient reason for a visit (MGMA).
  • What was tried first, and for how long. Payer criteria often require it. In an AAPC thread on BCBS denials, a coder quotes radiofrequency ablation criteria of "3 months of conservative therapy" and a prior block that reduced pain by 50% (AAPC forum, 2016).
  • Type, frequency, extent, site and duration. Anthem's definition tests each one, so the note should say why the service was given at this frequency and in this setting.
  • A diagnosis that supports the service. It has to be documented in the record and covered by the policy (next section).
  • Documentation that supports the level billed. For E/M visits, CMS says "Documentation should support the level of service reported" (section after next).

For therapy practices, see our physical therapy billing and PT and rehab pages.

How Do Diagnosis Codes Prove Medical Necessity?

Diagnosis codes prove medical necessity by matching the policy's list of covered diagnoses for the service. There is no single ICD-10 code for medical necessity; the diagnosis has to be one the policy accepts for that procedure.

Those lists change. In a 2023 AAPC thread, a Medicare denial for G0260 came back because "the diagnosis does not fall under the category of Group 3 codes" in the LCD (AAPC forum). In another, a payer was "denying all vitamin D testing, even with the code E55.9" (AAPC forum, 2018). Check the current LCD or payer policy, not last year's.

The code has to come from the record. Your coders and providers decide the diagnosis; see our medical coding page for how that review is staffed.

Does More Documentation Mean a Higher E/M Level?

More documentation doesn't mean a higher E/M level. Chapter 12, §30.6.1 of the Medicare Claims Processing Manual says: "Medical necessity of a service is the overarching criterion for payment in addition to the individual requirements of an E/M visit code." It adds that "The volume of documentation should not be the primary influence upon which a specific level of service is billed."

Since 1 January 2023, most E/M visit families are leveled by medical decision making or time, and history and exam "no longer impact visit level selection" (same section). A longer note doesn't raise the level; the decision making or time does.

When Do You Need an ABN?

For Medicare patients, you need an Advance Beneficiary Notice of Non-coverage (ABN, Form CMS-R-131) when you believe Medicare will likely deny a service as not reasonable and necessary. Chapter 30, §50 says the notice must be given before the service to shift financial liability to the patient.

What the ABN changes, from §50.9:

  • With a properly delivered ABN the patient agreed to, the patient can be held liable, at your usual and customary fee.
  • Without proper notice when one was required, the patient is relieved of liability. The practice can't collect from them and must refund anything already collected.

On the claim, the GA modifier means a signed ABN was obtained, and GZ means it wasn't (Chapter 30). For commercial plans, whether you can bill the patient after a medical necessity denial depends on your contract, a point AAPC coders make in the vitamin D thread. The front-end check belongs with insurance verification.

How Do You Read a Medical Necessity Denial?

A medical necessity denial arrives on the remittance as claim adjustment reason code 50. The X12 CARC list defines it as: "These are non-covered services because this is not deemed a 'medical necessity' by the payer."

Three things to check before reworking it:

  1. The group code. Chapter 1, §01.1 of the Claims Processing Manual explains that group codes assign financial responsibility to the provider or the patient, so CO versus PR tells you who owes it.
  2. The remark code. Remittance advice remark codes add detail to the CARC. An AAPC coder's advice on a CO-50: "your remark code would explain the reason" (AAPC forum, 2022).
  3. Whether it's a payer-side error. In a 2016 AAPC thread, a practice facing many Medicare medical necessity denials found the MAC had a "system wide issue" (AAPC forum). Check the MAC's notices before reworking a batch.

For repeat patterns, see our page on recurring denial reasons.

How Do You Appeal a Medical Necessity Denial?

You appeal by showing the payer, criterion by criterion, where the chart meets its policy. The deadlines come first:

  • Original Medicare: a redetermination request must be filed within 120 days from receipt of the initial determination notice (Medicare Claims Processing Manual, Chapter 29).
  • Medicare Advantage: the appeal must be filed within 65 days from the date on the plan's initial denial notice (Medicare.gov).
  • Commercial plans: the deadline is in the plan's denial notice and your contract.

Then build the appeal from the policy. Pull the written policy and map each criterion to a line in the chart; an AAPC coder describes overturning denials by pointing out "that all the guidelines were met" (AAPC forum, 2017). When the payer won't say which criterion failed, a complaint in the same thread, ask before you write.

Which denials to appeal and which to write off is your practice's decision. Our AR recovery and denial management page covers how that queue is staffed.

How Do You Prevent Medical Necessity Denials?

You prevent medical necessity denials before the claim goes out, at three points:

  1. Before the service. Check the LCD or payer policy for services that commonly deny, and issue an ABN when Medicare is likely to deny.
  2. Before the claim. Confirm the diagnosis on the claim is documented and on the policy's current covered list.
  3. After the remit. Track denial reasons so an error is caught early. MGMA describes a bone density scan denied for improper diagnosis coding, "an error that went undetected for months" (MGMA).

Who Does the Medical Necessity Work in a Practice?

Medical necessity work is split by role. The provider owns the clinical judgment, the note and the final say on appeals. The coder checks the diagnosis and procedure against the policy before submission. The biller reads the remit, pulls the remark code and builds the appeal packet. The office manager tracks deadlines.

myMedCrew places pre-vetted medical billers, coders and billing and appeals specialists who work your denial queue inside your own EHR and clearinghouse, to your cadence. Coding review, remit work and appeal packets run remotely; ABN capture at check-in can be on-site. Your practice keeps every appeal and write-off decision. Admin roles deploy in 15-20 business days, and if a candidate doesn't join, or isn't performing, we replace them. Published rates are on our medical billing services page, and multi-provider practices can start with our provider groups page.

Key Takeaways

  • Medicare's medical necessity test is §1862(a)(1)(A): services not reasonable and necessary for diagnosis or treatment aren't covered. Commercial plans publish their own definitions.
  • The payer's written policy (an NCD, LCD or medical policy) decides payment; the chart has to show how the service met it.
  • Medical necessity, not documentation volume, is the overarching criterion for E/M payment (CMS Chapter 12, §30.6.1).
  • An ABN (CMS-R-131) given before the service is what lets a practice bill a Medicare patient for a medical necessity denial; GA on the claim means one was signed.
  • CO-50 is the denial code; read the group code and remark code next to it, then appeal within 120 days (Original Medicare) or 65 days (Medicare Advantage).

Frequently asked questions

What is medical necessity?+

Medical necessity is the payer's test that a service was reasonable and necessary to diagnose or treat the patient's condition. For Medicare it comes from section 1862(a)(1)(A) of the Social Security Act; commercial plans publish their own definitions.

What is lack of medical necessity?+

Lack of medical necessity means the payer decided a service didn't meet its coverage criteria. It appears on the remittance as claim adjustment reason code 50: "These are non-covered services because this is not deemed a 'medical necessity' by the payer."

What qualifies as a medical necessity?+

Under commercial definitions such as Anthem's, a service qualifies when a practitioner using prudent clinical judgment would provide it, and it follows accepted standards of practice, is clinically appropriate in type, frequency, extent, site and duration, is not mainly for convenience, and is not more costly than an equally effective alternative.

What is the ICD-10 code for medical necessity?+

There isn't one. Medical necessity is shown by a documented diagnosis that is on the payer policy's list of covered diagnoses for that service.

Why would Medicare deny a claim for medical necessity?+

Medicare denies services found not reasonable and necessary for the diagnosis or treatment of illness or injury under section 1862(a)(1)(A), often because the diagnosis isn't covered by the national or local coverage determination for that service.

What is a 252 denial code?+

Claim adjustment reason code 252 means "An attachment/other documentation is required to adjudicate this claim/service." It comes with at least one remark code that says what is needed.

How long do you have to appeal a Medicare medical necessity denial?+

For Original Medicare, 120 days from receipt of the initial determination notice. For Medicare Advantage, 65 days from the date on the plan's initial denial notice.

Seeing CO-50s pile up in your denial queue?

Book a call and bring last month's denial report.

HIPAA-aligned · no spam.